Can Shipping’s Green Shift Survive Global Chaos?

Geopolitics, shadow fleets, and clashing climate rules are shaking up the seas. Lets break down how the maritime industry is fighting to stay compliant, secure, and sustainable—all at once.

Reading time: 9 min

The maritime sector has always faced challenges shaped by an evolving geopolitical context. However, as international tensions escalate – driven by political disputes, economic competition, and the rise of shadow fleets – the pursuit of sustainable transformation within shipping grows increasingly multifaceted.

Because global trade is so interconnected, decisions in one region ripple across supply chains – affecting costs, compliance, and environmental progress.

Shipping companies, subject to rigorous EU decarbonisation regulations and possibly forthcoming IMO mandates, must now navigate heightened unpredictability. Many companies that established their own climate goals did so under markedly different circumstances, prompting questions about the practical implementation and feasibility of those goals in today’s business context. These shifting dynamics present a host of challenges and invite broader reflection on how shipping companies safeguard their operations, workforce, regulatory compliance, and maritime infrastructure amid escalating geopolitical risks.

As international tensions rise, the imperative for business security and resilience becomes even more pronounced. Shipping companies must implement robust security measures to protect assets and maintain operational continuity—efforts that are essential, not optional, in today’s volatile environment. Regulators, while not directly responsible for asset protection, play a central role in shaping the security frameworks.

Legal and Ethical Frameworks: Implementation over Creation

International maritime law—overseen by the International Maritime Organization (IMO)—sets global safety and environmental standards. The EU, however, has introduced its own decarbonisation regulations, which in practice often diverge from IMO frameworks rather than complement them. This regulatory overlap has created friction rather than harmony, particularly as the IMO’s Net Zero Framework gains traction. From an industry perspective, this isn’t so much a dilemma as a compliance reality: companies follow what is mandated, and voluntary prioritization between security and environmental concerns is largely irrelevant. For states, however, the tension between national security imperatives and international sustainability commitments raises more complex legal and ethical questions.

Legal professionals play a critical role in navigating this regulatory complexity, though it’s important to clarify that they do not create regulation. Their expertise lies in interpreting, implementing, and managing the risks associated with regulatory frameworks. For instance, the ‘trifecta problem’ in the Framework for Ensuring the Uniform Implementation of IMO Instruments (FEUM) illustrates this complexity: the Document of Compliance (DOC) holder—often the ship manager—is the regulated entity, yet the shipowner or charterer may exert greater influence over compliance outcomes. This disconnect underscores the nuanced legal challenges in aligning emissions performance with regulatory responsibility.

A unified set of global regulations is crucial for the maritime industry, which operates across borders and faces universal challenges. The IMO’s role as a neutral regulatory authority is vital in maintaining a coherent framework that promotes safety, environmental protection, and fair competition worldwide. However, this coherence is increasingly undermined—not by the rescinding of national rules, but by their persistence. For example, the EU’s refusal to rescind its maritime decarbonization regulation, even as the IMO’s Net Zero Framework gains traction, exemplifies how regional regulation can conflict with global efforts. Rather than complementing IMO mandates, such national and regional rules risk regulatory fragmentation, which can weaken environmental progress and complicate accountability.

In this context, the principle of ‘no more favorable treatment’ becomes harder to uphold, especially when geopolitical interests drive uneven enforcement or overlapping mandates. To effectively address global challenges, the industry needs consistent international regulation. Where the IMO provides effective frameworks, national and regional authorities should refrain from introducing parallel rules on the same themes. Alignment—not duplication—is essential to ensure practical efficacy and collective progress.

Shadow Fleets and Illicit Practices: Addressing Legal Challenges

Shadow fleets that don't comply with established frameworks exemplify the threat to global maritime legal standards (ISO). These vessels, typically registered in jurisdictions with limited oversight, undermine emission reduction targets, competitive fairness, and maritime security. Their covert operations create significant enforcement challenges, impeding global efforts toward sustainable shipping.

The concept of the shadow fleet remains complex, largely because there is no universally agreed-upon definition of what it entails. What is clear, however, is that certain segments of the global fleet—often linked to states, owners, or shipping companies operating outside regulatory compliance—pose significant challenges. These vessels may sail under falsified flag documentation, lack insurance, evade sanctions, or disregard safety and environmental standards. Compounding the issue, some states deliberately choose not to inspect these vessels for compliance, further enabling their operations and eroding the integrity of international oversight.

This lack of a shared understanding and uneven enforcement makes it difficult to address the problem effectively. The existence of such non-compliant vessels undermines the notion of a universally governed fleet and creates an uneven playing field, where certain operators gain unfair advantages. Ultimately, this weakens efforts to uphold global standards and complicates the pursuit of truly sustainable and accountable maritime practices.

To address these evasive practices, legal professionals must prioritize the consistent enforcement of sanctions, reinforce flag state oversight, and improve transparency in vessel registration systems. In line with these efforts, the European Union has taken steps to sanction jurisdictions allegedly involved in supporting Russia’s shadow fleet through false flag operations. Instruments such as Port State Control, international anti-fleeting agreements, and rigorous inspection protocols are vital to harmonize safety and environmental standards across the maritime sector.

However, enforcement remains fragmented—not only because of regulatory loopholes, but also due to the deliberate inaction of certain states that choose not to inspect vessels for compliance. This lack of uniform enforcement enables non-compliant actors to operate with impunity and undermines the credibility of global oversight mechanisms. The industry must confront a difficult reality: without shared responsibility and consistent inspection practices, the downward spiral of regulatory avoidance may only deepen.

Green Technologies and Associated Risks: Legal Considerations

The hundreds of dual vessels that have been built and are on order, capable of running on alternative fuels like methanol, bio-LNG, and ammonia, demonstrate the industry’s commitment to decarbonization. Nevertheless, these innovations generate unique safety, liability, and operational concerns that require careful legal scrutiny. The relatively limited operational experience with some new fuels raises important questions regarding crew safety, responsibility allocation, and insurance coverage.

Legal experts must support the development and implementation of comprehensive safety regulations, licensing standards, and liability schemes tailored to emerging technologies. While they do not create regulation, their role is essential in interpreting legal frameworks, advising on compliance strategies, and managing the risks associated with new fuels and systems. Establishing reliable safety arrangements, substantiating sustainability claims, and conducting thorough risk assessments are critical. Importantly, risk assessments must extend beyond the vessel itself to include port infrastructure, storage, handling practices, and bunkering barges. They should also consider not only the company’s own approach but also the potential outcomes of incidents involving unrelated parties. For example, if an accident occurs during ammonia bunkering and people are harmed or killed, many ports could respond by halting or banning ammonia bunkering altogether, which would significantly impact supply chains and industry operations.

However, the industry must also consider the strategic implications of early adoption. While being first can confer reputational advantages, it also entails exposure to untested risks. This tension between innovation and caution underscores the need for robust due diligence and transparent communication with stakeholders.
A key challenge arises for shipping companies that have established net-zero emission targets earlier than the 2050 goal set by IMO and find themselves at risk of failing to meet these ambitions due to changed economic circumstances.

These firms could face legal action for greenwashing – misleading claims about their environmental commitments. As regulatory scrutiny intensifies, the number of greenwashing lawsuits may increase. Shareholders who have been misled by ambitious sustainability pledges may demand accountability, particularly when such claims lack substantiation or conflict with fiduciary obligations and the realities of day-to-day operations.

Balancing Security and Sustainability: A Unified Approach

A fundamental challenge persists: immediate security needs must be addressed in order to enable long-term sustainability—especially as sustainability is increasingly mandated through regulation, not optional. Interestingly, the emergence of shadow fleets—not complying with legal frameworks—can be seen as a perverse form of security for some actors, as they attempt to bypass regulations through illegal means. However, true security does not come from evading rules but from restoring the rule of law. The real security measure for the industry is turning to the legal profession to support the development of effective frameworks that level the playing field, preventing unlawful practices like shadow fleets from operating. This approach ensures that security is built on a solid, lawful foundation, enabling sustainable progress and fair competition.

A determinedly positive tone is essential. Considering the sector’s capacity for innovation, resilience, and collaboration underscores its “can-do” mindset that has benefited business for decades and increasingly benefits the environment. Rather than viewing sustainability as a burden, it should be embraced as a strategic opportunity—one that enhances competitiveness, attracts investment, and secures long-term viability.

Conclusion

Successfully managing the green transition amidst geopolitical uncertainty demands informed legal expertise, careful ethical considerations, and clear strategic planning. Addressing security challenges is a prerequisite to addressing the environmental imperatives. Shipowners aiming to reach net-zero emissions targets before 2050 should recognize that pursuing these goals is both ambitious and commendable. However, given the intricate and evolving landscape, it is highly advisable to seek rigorous legal guidance to effectively manage and mitigate potential legal and reputational risks if those targets may not be met. Proper legal counsel can help navigate the complexities, ensure compliance, and support robust, credible sustainability strategies.

Moreover, persuading stakeholders of the urgency of environmental action remains challenging amid a polarized global landscape. Regulatory authority is being tested by the shadow fleet, but the legal profession can help. Achieving meaningful change in this volatile environment requires determination, strategic foresight, and collaborative effort.

Ultimately, the industry’s path to genuine transformation involves making strategic, informed decisions - accepting necessary sacrifices, embracing transparency, and resisting shortcuts. The stakes are high, but the maritime sector has demonstrated resilience and innovativeness. The road ahead is not only necessary and feasible - it can be achieved through collective effort, ensuring that sustainability remains a truly global and inclusive endeavour. Like Indra Nooyi the Indian-born American business woman and former CEO of PepsiCo once said: "Purpose doesn't hurt margins. Purpose is how you drive transformation. If you don't transform the portfolio, you're going to stop top-line growth, and margins will decline anyway".